FM Classic: Return to Goodison – S1 E27

In 2015, Iain Macintosh went back in time to save Everton. After eight seasons he trudged away with significant emotional baggage. The following year, he tried it again. He was sacked after eight games. But in 2025, he returned one last time, he finished fourth and he qualified for the Champions League. But can he build on that success or will it all go horribly wrong?

Click here to read the previous episode

“Where the hell have you been?” barks Bill Kenwright at me across the car park.

I get out of my car, grab my bag out of the boot and stride over to him. This is ridiculous. I’m the manager of Everton Football Club and I’m being shouted at like I’m some sort of… actually, no, this is quite normal.

“We’ve been trying to reach you for days,” says Bill, aggressively jazz handing.

“I’ve been busy,” I snap.

“We need to talk,” says Bill. “It’s not working out.”

“We’re third, Bill!” I shout. “We’re third in the Premier League, we’re in the quarter-finals of the League Cup and we’ve qualified for the knockout round of the Europa League! What do you mean, it’s not working out?”

“That’s the problem,” says Bill. “People don’t want this, they don’t want success. People don’t want you to do well. And it’s really affecting the numbers.”

I give him a long, hard look.

“Look, Iain, we’re struggling to get people through the door. It’s possible we went too broad. We tried other sports, that didn’t work. We tried some music stuff, nothing happened there. We even had Danny Kelly doing a presentation on the Wu Tang Clan… that was actually quite cool, but still… we can’t seem to get people interested and the board… well… the board are wondering if it’s worth carrying on.”

“Of course it’s worth carrying on,” I wail. “This is the best it’s ever been, for Christ’s sake. I can’t stop now!”

“No-one wants it, Iain!” bellows Bill.

We both fall silent. A group of academy players have gathered by the main entrance. They stare at us in shock.

“I’m sorry, Iain,” says Bill. “I really am. But someone had to tell you to your face.”

“s’fine,” I sniffle.

“Look, it’s not all bad,” says Bill, putting his arm around me. “You’ve still got that podcast.”

I crumple into his arms and start to sob.

“One more game?”

Bill holds me and strokes my hair.

“One more game.”

Well, if this is to be my final game, then let’s make it a good one. We rested everyone for Europe in midweek, so we are full strength and I want all of my old boys back. So it’s Seamus and Leighton as full-backs, it’s Demigod Vida back in the defence, it’s James, Ross and Idrissa in the middle and you bet your shiny bottom that it’s big Rom up front.

I don’t tell the players what’s going on, but I think on some level that they know because they get straight into Palace from the first whistle. We’re making chances for fun and it isn’t long before Jonathan Biabiany drags a low cross along the edge of the box and Lukaku smashes it home. Just before half time, Coleman lofts one to the back stick and Filip Kostic nods in a second.

The second half goes exactly the way I want it. Nothing happens. Nothing at all. Not even half chances, just a few scuffed shots and desperate long range efforts. The game simply drains away. It’s the best going-away present I could have received. Why can’t they all be like this?

I thank the players for their efforts today and for the past 18 months and then I tell them that I’m leaving.

“But boss,” says Seamus. “We’re second in the table. Why on earth are you leaving?”

“Because no one wants it, Seamus. They want to see a middle-aged man struggling to survive. That’s the joke, you see. That’s what made it work. The juxtaposition of a hopeless nerd who loves a game, but the game hates him and it conspires against him and he gets sad. It’s no fun if the game loves him. No one wants to see a middle-aged man doing really well on a game he’s played for years. It just looks like boasting. So it’s over, Seamus, it’s over. And I’m sorry.”

No one says a word. I leave the dressing room quietly, I put on my big coat and my big hat, I pull the collar up and the brim down and I slip out into the crowds, leaving Goodison anonymously rather than, as I had once hoped I would, on an open top bus.

“We were good today, weren’t we, dad?” chirrups a small boy, walking hand in hand with his father in front of me.

“We were, son,” he says. “We really were.”

“Was it because of Lukaku, Dad? Or was it Kostic? Or was it Barkley? I like Barkley, Dad, he’s my favourite.”

“I think it was all of them,” says the dad. “It’s a team game, you see. You need everyone. Even the best player in the world couldn’t win without a good team around him. But most of all, you need a good manager to tie it all together.”

“Have we got a good manager, Dad?”

The father takes his time with the answer. He mulls it over.

“I think we have, son. I wasn’t sure about him at first, I wanted Ronald Koeman. But you can’t argue with results. He’s bought good players, he’s made us a much better team and he’s even brought back European football. I think he’s done just fine.”

I smile and I stand a little straighter.

“Yeah,” says the boy. “But he’s a such a dickhead, isn’t he?”

“He is, son,” says the dad. “He really is.”

Two weeks later, the phone rings. I stare at it for a bit. I haven’t been answering calls recently. It’s just journalists asking what went wrong and why I left and what I’m going to do next. The truth is that I don’t know what I’m going to do next.

Football management is what I know. It’s what makes me tick. If I’m ever out of work, I feel like there’s a piece of me missing.

The phone continues to ring. I lean towards it and check the number. It’s an international call, but there’s a strange code on it. Which country is +65?

I answer it.

“Iain Macintosh?” says a voice.

“Yes?” I say. “Who’s speaking?”

“My name is Peter Lim. Tell me, Iain, what do you know about Valencia?”

TO BE CONTINUED?

"Return To Goodison" will run for as long as people are still reading it and it will always be free. So if you like it, tell people about it. Push it on social media, whack it on Reddit or just send a link to a friend.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
24 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Alex
Alex
7 months ago

Iain, it’s been a pleasure as always but my word that was a tough read in the context of your comment on the last article. Gutted to see it end this way and hope you and the team figure out your next steps and we get to enjoy an FM26 journey in the near future. Best of luck, Alex.

Insert Name
Insert Name
7 months ago

Gutted that you’ve left Everton, I’ve not had time to play FM enough recently and being able to play it through you has been great. And truth be told I much prefer seeing you do well, as it meant you’ve had to create a full soap opera off pitch to keep some drama 🙂

Chris
Chris
7 months ago

If you really want to get those numbers up could I suggest finally starting up FM26 with a Sheffield Wednesday or Hamilton Accies save?

Sparta666
Sparta666
7 months ago

Valencia here we go!

The MIGician
The MIGician
7 months ago

Oh, you absolute motherfu—!! I read that with an increasing feeling of dread, thinking the series was ended and the website was shutting down. To be perfectly honest, I’m not entirely sure if it’s not?

I really hope not – I’ve checked for new articles most days for the last week and a half and was over the moon when I saw your Bluesky tweet-equivalent to say there was a new episode.

Fingers crossed you do terribly at Valencia and the reading numbers are huge!

Graham angus
Graham angus
7 months ago

Yassssss! We are not fucking leaving

Ola
Ola
7 months ago

Let’s go to Spain babyyyy!

Sion Davies
Sion Davies
7 months ago

It was beautiful whilst it lasted. I thought this was the perfect sequel to Newcastle. Shame it’s over and I’ll keep my eye out for your next venture!
Thank you for giving me a fun 10 minutes each week.

Kev
Kev
7 months ago

I think I speak for all of us when I say that we love this series, and would be willing to chip in to timeshare you coming round our houses to play a few hours of FM while muttering at an imaginary Duncan Ferguson.

👐

Brett
Brett
7 months ago

Iain, I’m keen to see this continue so I’ve looked at the numbers and they overwhelmingly say ‘More Steve Bould’.

In fact, there seems to be a real clamour for a backroom staff containing Bouldy and Big Dunc. Spain won’t know what hit ’em (spoiler: it was Dunc).

Matt
Matt
7 months ago

I’m so happy this is continuing!

Another vote for collecting all your previous loyal backroom staff for your new Spanish adventure. I’m sure they’ll all get along?

Oliver Davis
Oliver Davis
7 months ago

Great read as always Iain, I hope it continues in some form. Valencia could be fun!

Patrick
Patrick
7 months ago

Really hope this isn’t the end – winning or losing, it doesn’t matter to me, always a delight to read your work Iain. Fingers crossed!

Stijn
Stijn
7 months ago

I’ve followed many of your adventures over the past years and whilst it’s true that the ‘bad’ times sometimes seem more appealing to read: I love to see it going well also! It gives me hope that I can turn my fortunes around on my saves 😉
The creativity and nicknames makes everything worth to read: a good team turning against you and dropping down the table, but also proving the snakes wrong and climbing up it.

I really hope you’ll continue as it is a joy to have a noble writing project like Trackrecordmedia in these times. I’ll try to spread more of it to my friends. Best of luck!

Richard Chilver
Richard Chilver
7 months ago

More more more!

Toby
Toby
7 months ago

I’m really quite shocked by how gutted I am by this news, so will have to deflect and use LinkedIn platitudes as cover. Kudos Iain, looking forward to your next adventure! Let’s catch up soon, way to go!

Maybe the next role could also see the enforcement of some limiting philosophy to introduce some more comedy friction. Less Dogs of War, more possession-based domination with players born within 40 miles of the stadium?

Give Big Dunc one last scratch behind the ear from me

Andy Baxter
Andy Baxter
7 months ago

How can I just let you walk away,
Just let you leave without a trace?
When I stand here taking every breath with you, ooh ooh
You’re the only one who really knew me at all

THE KING IS DEAD, LONG LIVE THE KING

Phil
Phil
7 months ago

Come on, Iain – don’t leave us like this!

Continue your adventure in Spain, try out 26 or maybe dabble with the retro databases made by The Mad Scientist on a compatible version of FM.

Whatever it is, us content piggies will rub our trotters together before gobbling it all down!

Tom
Tom
7 months ago

You and Gary Neville have so much in common Iain. You were made for Valencia

A.Non
A.Non
7 months ago

I usually don’t comment but I do refresh and hope for a new entry every couple of days.

Always enjoyed your unique style of writing and I hope you give us more FM content. Whatever version, year or team it is!

RolandDeschain
RolandDeschain
7 months ago

Man, this sucks! I’m really going to miss this series, it’s been really great to follow along. Personally, I really enjoyed watching you succeed with this Everton team. Fingers crossed, the Big Mac will be back with the Big Dunc somewhere, someday

Richard
Richard
6 months ago

<Checks for ‘Iain Does Valencia’>
<sadly closes page>

KozaBob
KozaBob
5 months ago

I really enjoyed this. I saved up a bunch to read them back to back and I can’t help thinking I’m partly to blame for it not continuing (and people like me).

Sad that it ended but I’m very glad I was on the ride.

Thank you Iain!